Things to Consider When Choosing Between a Care Home or Home Care

by | May 20, 2024 | 0 comments

Selecting the ideal care plan for a senior family member is a big choice that affects their happiness, wellbeing, and quality of life. Families in Hawaii frequently struggle with the decision of whether to put their loved ones in a care facility or choose at-home care. Because each option has advantages and disadvantages of its own, it is important to weigh a number of considerations before deciding which is best for your loved one.

Understanding Home Care

Professional caregivers who specialize in home care assist elderly people in their own residences. This kind of care is very adaptable and provides individualized support according to the needs of the individual. Assistance with activities of daily living (ADLs) such as mobility, bathing, using the restroom, preparing meals, managing medications, and light housework is a common feature of services. There are two primary categories of home care:

  1. Personal Care: Focuses on assisting with physical tasks such as bathing, dressing, and mobility.
  2. Companion Care: Involves providing companionship, emotional support, and assistance with household tasks.

Benefits of In-Home Care

  • Comfort and familiarity: Elderly people live in their own homes where they are surrounded by things they are acquainted with and personal items, which can be very reassuring for individuals who are suffering from dementia or Alzheimer’s.
  • Independence: Seniors receiving home care are able to preserve a greater degree of autonomy and control over their daily schedules.
  • Personalized Care: Caregivers offer individualized attention, customizing their services to each person’s unique requirements and preferences.
  • Cost-effective: For those who do not require critical medical attention, home care may be less expensive than care in a nursing facility.
  • Family Involvement: By offering greater assistance and supervision, families can take a more active role in the caregiving process.

Cons to In-Home Care

  • Limited Medical Support: Seniors with complicated health issues may find that home care does not offer the same level of medical help as a nursing facility.
  • Caregiver Reliability: Selecting a trustworthy home care agency is essential because the caliber of care is contingent upon the caregiver’s abilities and dependability.
  • Modifications to a Home: It may be necessary to make expensive changes to some homes in order to guarantee accessibility and safety.
  • Limited Social Interaction: Compared to a community living setting in a care facility, seniors may have less social interaction.
Providing Home Care To Seniors In Hawaii

Understanding Care Homes

Types of Care Homes

Care homes, also known as nursing homes or assisted living facilities, provide residential care for seniors who need continuous support and supervision. These facilities vary in the level of care they offer:

  1. Assisted Living Facilities: Provide help with ADLs and basic medical care while promoting as much independence as possible.
  2. Nursing Homes: Offer more intensive medical care, staffed with licensed nurses and healthcare professionals available 24/7.
  3. Memory Care Units: Specialized care homes designed for seniors with dementia or Alzheimer’s, offering structured environments and specialized care programs.

Benefits of Care Homes

  • All-Inclusive Care: Care facilities offer 24-hour medical and non-medical support, guaranteeing that all requirements are fulfilled on time.
  • Security and Safety: These facilities have emergency response systems and secure surroundings because they were created with senior safety in mind.
  • Social Opportunities: By providing residents with social activities, group outings, and communal dining, the danger of loneliness and isolation is diminished.
  • Professional Staff: To provide a higher caliber of care and knowledge, care homes employ nurses, therapists, and other trained professionals as well as caregivers.
  • Regular Environment: Seniors with cognitive impairments can benefit from a regular routine since it offers stability and consistency.

Cons of Care Homes

  • Loss of Independence: Moving to a care home can be challenging for seniors who value their independence and autonomy.
  • Adjusting to New Environment: The transition to a care home can be stressful, and some seniors may struggle to adapt to the new surroundings.
  • Cost: Care homes can be expensive, with costs varying based on the level of care and the type of facility.
  • Less Personalized Care: Although care is comprehensive, the ratio of caregivers to residents may mean less personalized attention compared to home care.
  • Potential for Negative Experiences: Not all care homes provide the same level of quality, making it essential to research and choose a reputable facility.

Making the Decision

The decision between home care and a care home is very personal and is based on your loved one’s preferences and particular situation. The following situations could influence your decision:

1. Healthy and Fairly Independent Seniors

If your loved one is relatively healthy and independent but needs help with daily tasks, home care might be the best option. They can enjoy the comfort of their own home while receiving the necessary support.

2. Seniors Facing Health Challenges

A care home can offer seniors who struggle to live alone the medical attention and social engagement they require. This choice guarantees that they are constantly being watched over and helped by experts.

3. Couples with Different Care Needs

In situations where one member of a pair needs more intensive care than the other, home care can provide the flexibility that is necessary to support each person. A nursing home can be a better option if both need high levels of care.

4. Seniors with Serious Health Problems

A nursing home is frequently the best option for elderly people with significant health issues who need ongoing medical care. These facilities are capable of managing complicated medical requirements and offer 24-hour care.


When choosing between home care and assisted living facilities for your elderly loved one in Hawaii, it’s important to take into account their independence, financial resources, social needs, and overall health. Each option has benefits and drawbacks, and the best decision will depend on the particular circumstances surrounding your loved one. You can guarantee that your loved one gets the greatest care and support possible by carefully evaluating their needs and investigating the various care providers. Contact us!

Home Care Services

Articles You May Like

7 ​​Healthy Aging Tips for Older Adults

Healthy Aging Tips for Older Adults Aging is an inevitable part of life, but it doesn’t have to mean a decline in happiness or quality of life. By embracing a proactive approach, older adults can enjoy their golden years with vitality and joy. Healthy aging involves a...

Caregiving Services for Senior Living in Haleiwa, Oahu

Nestled on the iconic North Shore of Oahu, Haleiwa is a charming coastal town renowned for its laid-back atmosphere, stunning beaches, and vibrant community spirit. Amidst the lush landscapes and ocean breezes, families in Haleiwa seek compassionate and reliable care...

Specialized Companion Care for Seniors in Waipahu, Hawaii

Are you in need of a trustworthy in-home elder care provider in Waipahu, Hawaii that provides exceptional care on your terms? When it comes to ensuring the well-being and quality of life for seniors, Mālama Maika’i in-home care services in Waipahu, Hawaii, stands out...

Trusted Respite Care for Seniors in Mililani, Hawaii

Our in-home care and respite care services are designed to offer temporary relief care services to loved ones of those who need care, providing a much-needed break for family caregivers. Your loved ones will not only receive the highest quality of care, but they will...

Quality Home Care Services for Seniors in Pearl City, Hawaii

As we age, maintaining mobility and independence becomes crucial for seniors to meet their social needs and stay connected with the community. Having access to specialized senior transportation services, such as transportation to medical appointments, assistance with...

Companion Care Services in Aiea, Hawaii

Welcome to Malama Maika'i Health and Wellness Alliance’s service locations page, dedicated to providing exceptional companion care services in Aiea, Hawaii. Our mission is to enhance the well-being and independence of seniors by offering comprehensive home care...

Home Care Near Me

Call Us To Learn More

Phone Number


E-mail Address